Best island of the Caribbean?

[chithanh119]

Just wanted to know "Best Island of the Caribbean" and why? Is it Caymen Islands or Virigin Islands? or yours?

 

[earl_m]

Thats a hard one to answer. I have been to maybe 20 islands, There is not one island
that stands out more than the other. I love them all. !!

 

[rhen33]

St John US Virgin Island.

 

[Mbandy]

A very interesting question and a very tough one to answer. On the one hand you feel like you've seen one cruise port, you've seen them all. Bars, beaches and jewelry stores. On the other hand each port of call has it's own unique flavor. I have a favorite thing about each port I have visited.

My favorite itinerary is the one out of Tampa that takes in Cozumel, Costa Maya, Belize and Roatan. If I had to narrow it down to one it would probably be the Cays off the coast of Belize.

 

[rocster]

By far for us it's Dominica, so non-typical Caribbean island, the only thing I recognized there was a KFC restaurant. Beautiful lush and unspoiled island, my second favorite id St Johns USVI.

 

[Jody H]

St. John, by far! We've rented villas for the past 3 years there and adore the island!